A robot can pass its sensor checks with three breakout boards and fail with just one. Add two more boards and it can fail again, for a different electrical reason. Each module may bring both capacitance and another pair of pull-up resistors. Removing a module changes the circuit as surely as adding one.
Qualify I2C at the level of the supported assembly, separately for SDA and SCL. For every allowed combination, count the fitted pull-ups, bound the capacitance, and check both rise time and the current demanded from the weakest device pulling the line low. A clean trace from the fully populated prototype does not establish that the reduced configuration works.
The worked example below shows that failure pattern, then checks a different pull-up arrangement across all 31 nonempty combinations of five hypothetical boards. The calculations are executed synthetic examples, not measurements from a robot.










